Into everyone’s life a Moment must fall. That Moment landed for me during a gathering at a conference on peer relationships – how children made friends and the positive effects of friendships on child development. We were standing around in a large-ish group, not-so-greats, wanna-be-greats, and graduate student hanger-ons. Interestingly, for a group who studied everything from what made kids popular to what created bullies, we were a particularly competitive and mean-spirited clutch of researchers. At least that was how it sounded by our verbal exchanges which was more about seeing who would be hacked to bits next than about discussing how to make school an emotionally safer environment. The irony, however, was lost on me as I jockeyed to be one of the group.
I don’t recall what I said; I’m actually surprised I’ve forgotten. A graduate student I admired made a comment about her work. I snapped back with what I thought was a witty come-back. The stunned silence said otherwise and someone quietly exclaimed, “Oh. That was horribly mean.” I don’t remember much else after that. There was a feeling of shame but more one of confusion. In a whirlwind of cutting remarks and digs at competence, I couldn’t understand why my words were judged so profoundly lacking in kindness. I still don’t know but it doesn’t matter. The lesson was well learned.
It was a powerful Moment in which I suddenly felt the lineage of hurtful speech bearing down on me. I think there are times when we have this felt sense of the stream of all our ancestors. This was one. It wasn’t only about Right Speech – or in this case generations of Wrong Speech. It also brought into high relief the sense of verbal entitlement I had inherited from my family’s way of communicating: a belief that we could say anything about anything to each other and the supposition of love was the license. Of course, if fair play and willingness to take responsibility were part of the agreement, it might (might?) have passed for teasing. But there was a one-sidedness to the Unmindful Speech and a scurrying into denial when someone (usually me) broke down. “Oh we’re just joking.” “You’re too sensitive.”
Back story aside, I felt in that Moment something needed to change, this was not who I wanted to be. I don’t know who that person was who lowered the boom on me at the conference but I owe her my practice. Now, roses don’t fall out of my mouth and I can get pretty foul at times but I notice that edge when my speech is not going to be useful. I’m learning that Right Speech is not about “make nice” words and tones. It’s not about tearing one person down to build up a relationship with another. It’s not about trading integrity for belonging. It’s neither seduction nor collusion.
It’s about speaking to my truth, going to essence, trusting that what needs to emerge will, and not measuring my words against my preferred outcome. It’s also about noticing reactivity and taking responsibility for what happens when highly practiced tracks in my brain send the signals before I can hit “mute speakers.”
Thank you for practising,
How fortunate they singled you out! Otherwise it would have just been another moment! ^_^
I have similar experiences, it didn’t sound so bad when I heard someone else say it, but for some reason it sounded really bad when I repeated it…
The Dharma Realm must like us (in a tough-love sort of way!), it doesn’t want us to fail!
Perhaps in the end, Right Speech functions only to help us all awaken. Any kind of language, spoken with bodhisattva intent, will serve.
Thanks for having the humility to share this helpful story. Sometimes it is not a comment but a look that can wake us up to what we have said. I am sure we have all had those moments of regret either when called or just hearing what comes out of our mouths. It can be very sobering and as you point out helpful moment!
In my family funny comments that were at someone’s expense passed for acceptable. I have come to think before I spill out something just for a laugh.
I am deeply resonating here… Our family too had this comedic criticalness that passed as “I’m just kidding” and “you’re too sensitive” – using humor to get their digs/darts in – which I somehow knew wasn’t “right” – yet fell into that kind of verbal armoring myself – I love the phrase “verbal entitlement.” I also experienced those deafening silences outside of the family dynamic when I thought I was just being funny, especially with in-laws; how *not* to make an impression… ouch… deep regret… But like you, it created the opening that was needed, that bloomed into the awareness of how I use my words – although that has taken years!
I also find it interesting that you said: “speaking *to* my truth” and not “speaking my truth.” Big difference, as speaking my truth can be another cover for getting the digs in… Love it…
Thank you for your authenticity! Great post!
Thank you, my friends! It’s taken a while for me to see that these experiences are, as Joseph says, ways of learning not to fail.
Waking up, waking up, (not hitting snooze), waking up….